Blossom Advocates Book a free call

Home/School zones

Is it worth paying $300,000 more for a school zone?

What Melbourne families should know before paying a school zone premium, and three situations where it's worth thinking twice.

Fiona Chen
Fiona Chen, Founder / Lead Buyer's Agent 28 September 2026

If you've looked at homes in a Melbourne school zone, you've probably seen this. In the same area, two similar houses are for sale, but one sits in a double zone, with a sought after primary school and secondary school, and it's priced $200,000 or even $300,000 higher.

At the inspection, the selling agent reminds you that both schools are among the best public schools around. When you try to negotiate, you hear something like: "For this zone, the price is already very reasonable, and several other buyers are looking closely."

So you pause and wonder whether the premium is really worth it. In this article, I'll share the data, what we see in the market and what our clients have experienced, including three situations where I'd encourage you to think twice, even when the premium seems reasonable.

How big is the school zone premium?

The Real Estate Institute of Victoria (REIV) compared house prices inside popular government school zones with homes about one kilometre outside, over the 12 months to March 2025. The gaps were significant.

The Balwyn High School and East Doncaster Secondary College zones also carried premiums above 10%.

These figures only look at secondary school zones. When a home sits in both a strong primary and secondary zone, we usually see more buyers at inspections, stronger competition at auction and far less room to negotiate.

Why families are willing to pay it

For many families, it comes down to simple maths. Private secondary school fees can exceed $40,000 a year, so a $200,000 to $300,000 premium is roughly the cost of six years of private secondary education. The difference is that a home is an asset, while school fees are money spent. A good school zone can offer both a quality public education and a home that may grow in value.

The deeper reason is scarcity. The Glen Waverley Secondary College zone, for example, is compact, roughly a two kilometre radius, and the school has held a strong ranking for years. Only a limited number of homes in the zone sell each year, while the number of families hoping to get in keeps growing. That's a big part of why homes inside the zone sell for close to 30% more.

For these families, the purchase is about planning a stable education path, not just buying a home, so they tend to be less sensitive to price. As long as the school's reputation holds, that demand doesn't fade. It's why quality homes in popular zones still attract strong competition, even as higher interest rates cool the wider market.

So the premium has its logic. But even when it looks reasonable, not every school zone home is worth buying.

1. When the premium has already priced in future growth

To get into a zone, many buyers compromise on land size, floor plan or how well the home will hold its value. In my experience, this is the risk buyers most often overlook.

Cotality's 2025 analysis of nine popular school catchments across Sydney and Melbourne found that most carried a price premium, yet six recorded weaker capital growth over the past 15 years than comparable homes just outside the zone. School zone homes still grow in value, but when the premium is already fully reflected in the price, there's less room left to rise.

Five years ago, one family bought a three bedroom, one bathroom house on more than 1,000 square metres in the Vermont Secondary College zone for $1.5 million. The land was generous, so they felt the home would grow well even if the house itself was small. They then spent a considerable amount renovating.

Today, with a second child and plans for their parents to move in, three bedrooms and one bathroom no longer work. They'd like a five bedroom home, but their current house would likely sell for around $1.2 million. After the purchase price and renovation costs, selling now would mean a loss.

They bought near the top of the market, and the home itself involved compromises in size and layout. The premium paid for the zone delivered neither the growth they hoped for nor a home that suits their family for the long term.

2. When the home sits on the edge of the zone

An edge of zone home is technically inside the boundary, but only a street or two, or even a few houses, away from it. I usually suggest thinking carefully about these, because school zones change.

The Victorian Department of Education reviews zones every year. For 2026, 19 new schools opened and around one in eleven primary school zones were redrawn. Changes like these almost always start at the edges.

If the home sits in the heart of the zone, a boundary change rarely affects it. On the edge, any future adjustment could move it from inside the zone to outside. That creates two risks:

  • Your child's enrolment. If your child hasn't started school yet, a boundary change can take away the certainty you paid for.
  • Your future sale price. In 10 or 15 years, the next buyer won't pay a school zone premium for a home that may no longer be in the zone.

Where you can, it's safer to avoid homes right on the boundary.

3. When you buy too early

Some families pay a large premium when their children are very young, or not even born yet, so they can settle into the right zone once and for all. Planning ahead is sensible, but plans often change. Among the families we've helped, these decisions most often start to feel uncertain five to seven years later.

Recently, a couple came to us feeling quite anxious. Six years ago, while expecting their second child, they bought land in the Doncaster East double zone for Serpell Primary School and East Doncaster Secondary College. This was going to be their forever home, so they built with the best materials and top of the range appliances. Between the land and the build, it was already a premium investment at the time.

Then, when their eldest daughter reached Year 5, they felt a public secondary school wasn't the right fit for her personality, and chose a private girls' school on the other side of the city. The drive takes 40 to 50 minutes in peak traffic, and public transport takes over an hour each way with a change. So they decided they needed to move closer to the school.

The selling agent's appraisal came in at roughly what they had spent on the land and the build, meaning almost no return on paper. That made the decision very hard, and now, with the enrolment deadline approaching, they have to decide.

The premium they paid for the zone was never really used by their children, and because they held the home for a relatively short time, it didn't deliver the growth they expected either. Often, waiting until your children are a little older, and their education path is clearer, is the more rational time to buy into a school zone.

So, is the school zone premium worth it?

It isn't a simple yes or no.

The premium makes sense when your child genuinely needs that school, the home sits in the core of the zone, the floor plan, land, street and liveability all support the price, and you plan to hold for the long term.

It can become a burden when you sacrifice too much to get in, or commit heavily before your child's education path is clear.

Sources: Real Estate Institute of Victoria school zone research, 12 months to March 2025. Cotality school catchment analysis, July 2025. Victorian Department of Education.

Copyright © 2026 Blossom Advocates